At Caputo’s, our team doesn’t just sell specialty foods, we live them. Every week at our Holladay location, our General Manager and staff create a Pairing of the Week to celebrate the creativity and joy of artisan food.
Until now, these discoveries lived only in our internal Slack. They were too good to keep hidden, so we’re sharing a curated “Best Of” list featuring artisan cheese, craft chocolate, tinned seafood, charcuterie, bitters, and more. Each pairing is designed to inspire your next cheese board, cocktail hour, or cozy night in.
Best Pairings from Holladay
1. Chocolate Meets Cheese and Marmalade (07/02)
– Rocky Mountain Sky Cheese, creamy and rich, made locally
– Yakami Orchards Passion Fruit Marmalade, sweet-tart tropical brightness
– Goodnow Farms Esmeraldas 70% Dark Chocolate, smooth with notes of fruit and nuts
Why it works: tangy fruit bridges the richness of cheese and chocolate, creating a balanced and indulgent bite.
2. The Showstopper Quartet (07/09)
– Spianata Calabrese, fiery and bold salami
– Double Skull Taleggio, creamy funk and richness
– Orange Blossom Honey, delicate floral sweetness
– Toketti Crackers, light and crisp
Why it works: sweet, spicy, creamy, and crunchy, every flavor note shines.
3. Pecorino Romano and Cipollini Onions (07/16)
– Pecorino Romano, bold, salty, nutty kick
– Cipollini Onions, caramelized into candy-like sweetness
Why it works: sharp sheep’s milk cheese balanced by onion’s gentle sweetness.
4. Sardines, Pickles and Capers (07/23)
– Jose Gourmet Sardines in Olive Oil with Lemon
– Torres Pickle Chips
– Salted Capers
Why it works: briny, tangy, citrusy layers that elevate a humble sardine snack.
5. Robiola, Crackers and Truffle Honeycomb (07/30)
– Robiola Bosina, creamy Italian treasure
– Toketti Rosemary Crackers
– Truffle Honeycomb
Why it works: elegant, decadent, and perfect for an aperitivo.
6. Citrus and Shortbread (08/06)
– Fior d’Arancio, sparkling orange blossom wine
– Rustic Bakery Vanilla Shortbread
Why it works: bright citrus cuts buttery richness.
7. Kunik, Fig and Pecan Shortbread (08/13)
– Kunik Cheese, tangy goat-cow blend
– Dalmatia Fig Spread, fruity sweetness
– Rustic Bakery Pecan Shortbread
Why it works: cheese, fruit, and nut, a timeless trio.
8. Truffle, Spice and Rye (08/20)
– Alta Langa Truf Tre Latte, truffle-infused triple-milk cheese
– Barnacle Kelp Chili Crisp, umami-rich heat
– Potter’s Wisconsin Rye Crackers
Why it works: earthy, spicy, and rustic, an adventurous bite.
9. Zero-Proof Mocktail (08/27)
– Amargo Chuncho Bitters
– Lurisia Sparkling Water
– Fresh lemon or lime juice
Why it works: botanical complexity in a refreshing, non-alcoholic sip.
10. Tuna Pâté with Hot Sauce (09/03)
– Gueyu Mar Chargrilled Tuna Pâté
– Chacho Hot Sauce
– Caputo’s House Crostini
Why it works: smoky, spicy, and rich, comfort food gone gourmet.
11. Brewed Chocolate and Bitters (09/10)
– Mānoa Brewing Chocolate, cacao brewed like coffee
– Bitterhousewife Cardamom Bitters or Workhorse Rye Pumpkin Bitters
Why it works: cozy and spiced, the fall upgrade to hot chocolate.
Why Pairings Matter
Pairings show us how specialty foods connect. They highlight unexpected flavors and make entertaining effortless. From artisan cheeses with fruit spreads, to tinned seafood with gourmet snacks, to bitters in a sparkling aperitif, the Holladay team’s creations prove that the right pairing can transform simple ingredients into something extraordinary.
Try Them Yourself
Which pairing will you try first? Share your own combinations with us, your idea could inspire the next Pairing of the Week.
For more inspiration, visit our specialty food shop or stop by Caputo’s Holladay to see what our team is working on next.
FAQ
What makes a good pairing?
Balance: contrasting textures and flavors that bring out the best in each other.
Do pairings always involve cheese?
Not at all. From chocolate to tinned seafood to cocktail bitters, good pairings can happen anywhere.
How do I build these pairings into a single bite?
These are all really simple combos so don’t stress if your way is not the same as ours. Just have fun and make it look appealing to you!
Where can I buy these products?
Most are available in Caputo’s stores or online at caputos.com.